Why prettier isn't always better. Here's What's Hiding Underneath.
October 30, 2026
We recently lost a customer. That doesn't happen often, so it stuck with us.
He'd been with us for over a year, and in that time his business grew. We were proud of that.
He was also getting the same calls and emails every local business owner gets. SEO "experts" telling him he was leaving money on the table, that his site needed to look more professional, that he should be spending more. Over a year of that, it adds up. Eventually he was convinced, and he moved to a custom-built site.
We don't blame him. The new site is beautiful. Big bold headlines, great photos, smooth animations. It's fast on a phone, and Google's own quality test scores it in the mid-90s or higher for speed, accessibility, and best practices. If you showed it to ten people, ten people would say it looks great.
What isn't obvious is what's happening underneath. When we ran it through our free Website Checkup, we found problems that are probably costing him customers right now, and none of them show up when you look at the site in a browser.
This isn't about one developer. We see the same pattern over and over: a site that looks finished but isn't. So here's what to watch for if you're getting a new website, or just got one.
Problem 1: Every old link now leads nowhere
After a year, Google knew his business well. It had his service pages indexed, each at its own address. Those pages had built up a history: people searched, clicked, and called.
The new site moved every service to a new address. Nothing tells Google or anyone else where the old pages went. In web terms, there are no redirects.
So when someone searches for one of his services and clicks the result Google still has on file, they land on a "Page not found." The search result is correct. The page behind it is gone.
It gets worse. Normally, a missing page tells Google "this is gone" with an error code, and Google updates its results. On this site, every address, real or not, reports back that everything is fine and only says "not found" after the page loads in a browser. Google calls this a soft 404. It means Google is slower to notice the old pages are gone, junk addresses can get indexed, and broken links look healthy to any tool checking them.
A redirect is a one-line instruction: "this page moved here." Set one up for every old address and the visitor lands on the right page, and most of the standing that page earned carries over. Skip it and you're starting from scratch, with a trail of dead ends behind you.
If you're changing websites: before launch, list every page on your old site and make sure each one redirects to its new home. This is the single most common thing that gets missed in a redesign, and the most expensive.
Problem 2: AI assistants get a blank page
When we looked at what the new site sends when something other than a browser asks for a page, the answer was nothing. Zero words. No headline. Every page had the same title. All the text a visitor sees (well over a thousand words on the homepage alone) only exists after the browser runs the site's code and draws it on screen.
A lot of modern sites are built like apps instead of pages. Rather than sending a finished page, the server sends an empty shell plus a bundle of JavaScript, and your browser assembles the page on the spot. The tools that build sites this way make it the default unless someone deliberately sets up the alternative (called server-side rendering or pre-rendering). In a browser, you can't tell the difference. That's why nobody catches it.
Google does run JavaScript. It fetches your page, puts it in a queue, and renders it later, so it eventually sees what you see. But Google is the exception. Most other things that read your website don't run JavaScript at all:
- AI assistants. When someone asks ChatGPT, Claude, or Perplexity to recommend a business, the crawlers behind those tools read the page as it's delivered. The most recent public study we've seen of AI crawler traffic found that none of the major ones render JavaScript. If your page arrives empty, the AI gets an empty page. You can't be recommended for services the AI never saw you describe.
- Link previews. When a customer texts your link to a friend or shares it in a Facebook group, the preview card comes from the raw page too. On this site, every page previewed with the same generic title, and the preview image was missing because it pointed to a partial address like
/images/logo.pnginstead of a full URL. - Everyone else. Other search engines, directories, SEO tools, uptime monitors. Many take the raw page at face value.
Is AI search a big share of a local business's traffic today? Probably not. But it's the fastest-growing way people ask for recommendations, and it's one of the few places a small business can still show up ahead of the big players. Being absent by accident is a bad trade for a nice animation.
Problem 3: The website and the Google profile disagree
For a local business, your Google Business Profile is often what people see first. Your website is where they go to confirm it. When the two don't match, both lose credibility.
On this site, the website listed one set of weekend hours and the Google profile listed another. One of them is wrong. A customer who trusts the wrong one either shows up when the business is closed, or doesn't call because they think it is. Google also treats consistency between your site and your profile as a trust signal.
The new site also doesn't link to the Google listing. A "find us on Google Maps" link that goes to your actual listing is an easy way to tie the two together.
The mismatch goes deeper than what visitors see. Good sites include structured data, a block of code that tells Google your hours, location, service area, and social profiles in a format it can read without guessing. The new site has the basics (name, phone, services, service area) but is missing hours, map coordinates, and the social profiles it links to elsewhere. Its FAQ content has no matching markup either.
It also marks up its own star rating. Google's guidelines say it won't show review stars that a local business publishes about itself, and that markup can be flagged. It's a common mistake and an easy one to remove.
The smaller stuff
None of these sink a business on their own, but they add up:
- No canonical tag, and every page loads both with and without a trailing slash. Two addresses for the same page, and nothing telling Google which one counts.
- One shared page title long enough to get cut off in search results, and a shared description longer than Google will show.
- A developer's leftover "TODO" note still sitting in the site's robots.txt file.
- No analytics or conversion tracking at all. Nobody can tell whether the new site brings in more calls than the old one. Which, given everything above, is the question that matters most.
Why "it looks great" catches none of this
Every problem above is invisible in a browser. The design review passes. The speed test passes. The owner opens the site on their phone and it's beautiful.
That's what makes it dangerous. A slow or ugly site gets complaints. A site that looks perfect but sends old customers to dead ends and hands AI tools a blank page gets compliments, while the business wonders why the phone isn't ringing like it used to.
Before you launch a new site, ask for these
If you're about to switch websites, or someone is pitching you one, these are fair questions to ask:
- Is every old page redirected to its new address? Ask for the list.
- Does each page arrive with its own text and title, before any JavaScript runs? If the answer involves the words "single-page app," ask how it's pre-rendered.
- Do the hours, phone, and address match the Google Business Profile exactly?
- Is the business's structured data complete, including hours, location, and social profiles, and free of self-awarded review stars?
- Do missing pages return a real "not found" error?
- Is analytics installed, so you can compare before and after?
A good developer will have answers to all six. If you get blank looks, that tells you something too.
How to check your own site
We built the Website Checkup to answer these questions without needing to read code. Enter your web address and in about two minutes you get a plain-English report covering:
- Google's speed and quality scores: speed, accessibility, and best practices, plus a score for how readable your site is to AI agents.
- What AI assistants and link previews see: page by page, what your site sends compared to what a browser draws.
- Your Google profile: whether your hours, phone, and website match what's on your site, and whether the two are linked.
- Whether Google understands your business: which business details are in your structured data, which are missing, and which are mistakes.
- A ranked list of fixes: most important first, written for a business owner, with the technical details tucked underneath for whoever builds your site.
It's free. If everything comes back green, great. You've confirmed it. If it doesn't, you'll have a specific list to hand your web developer.
The bottom line
We hope our former customer does well. None of these problems are permanent. They're all fixable by someone who knows to look. The hard part is knowing to look.
Design matters. People judge a business by its website in seconds, and a good-looking site earns trust. But looks are the part you can see. The parts that decide whether customers find you in the first place, what Google, AI assistants, and link previews actually receive, are invisible unless you check.
Pretty and working aren't opposites. You should have both. Just don't assume one means the other.
Sources
- Google Search Central, Site moves with URL changes (redirects when pages move)
- Google Search Central, HTTP status codes and network errors (soft 404s)
- Google Search Central, Understand the JavaScript SEO basics
- Vercel, The rise of the AI crawler
- Google Search Central, Review snippet structured data (self-serving reviews for local businesses)
- Google Search Central, Local business structured data
- The Open Graph protocol (how link previews are built)
Questions About Your Website, SEO, or AI Search?
Whether you're ready to get started or just want to learn more about how we can help your business get found online, we're here to answer your questions.
Whether you're ready to get started or just want to learn more about how we can help your business get found online, we're here to answer your questions.